In 2024, it is almost impossible not to draw parallels between the current atmosphere and Germany in 1933—a period marked by exemption and an outward appearance of calm. The reason for my unease is Donald Trump’s peculiar specificity about his authoritarian aspirations. His declarations, coupled with the alarming statements from those aligning with him, hint a disturbing intent to pursue dictatorial actions from day one. Witnessing such malice filtered through incompetence, with a select few displaying a modicum of conscience, is disconcerting.
The imperative for a pro-democracy movement becomes clear when we confront the distinct threat presented by Trump.
Unlike other Republicans, he has cultivated a cult-like movement, surpassing mere poll numbers. This MAGA cult is fervently dedicated to propelling him towards a dictatorial position. Consequently, there is a pressing need to counteract this with a pro-democracy movement—a collective initiative at the grassroots level aimed at nurturing a sense of belonging and shared purpose.
An unresolved question of our time revolves around whether pro-democracy leaders and movements can ignite a passionate response. Is it possible for those advocating for the rule of law, pluralism, economic justice, and human rights to not only articulate these ideas but also tap into fundamental human needs? These needs include a sense of belonging, the soothing of anxieties, answers to fears, the experience of hope, or simply a connection felt at the end of dreary days.
In the peculiar dynamics of the Trump era, where the right has increasingly transformed into a movement of passion rather than reason, emphasizing emotional appeal over policy solutions, the political left has taken a contrasting path.
The current electoral left is notably cerebral. It tends to avoid emotional appeals and lacks emphasis on communal gatherings in public spaces, catchy slogans, or compelling visuals. As Trump adopts a more carnival-like approach, leaders on the left seem inclined to project an image reminiscent of the unassuming heads of state in many European capitals—individuals diligently avoiding any hint of excitement.
The Democratic Party’s current approach, primarily centered around fundraising, falls short of addressing the crucial elements required for a thriving movement. It’s time to bridge racial coalitions, engage in meaningful dialogue, and empower communities. We must move beyond online activism, recognizing that true political participation involves more than digital expression.
Blaming Trump is insufficient; the responsibility lies with the failure to build a pro-democracy movement. The absence of such a force leaves a void that should be filled with a compelling and inclusive movement, uniting people across races and ages. The movement should address the underlying questions causing anxiety, offering a sense of identity and purpose in a changing world.
To thrive in the face of challenges, Democrats must go beyond merely surviving. The key lies in organizing people into a movement that transcends partisan lines, providing answers to deeper questions and instilling a sense of excitement about building a better country. The blueprint for success exists, as demonstrated by Barack Obama in 2007. It’s time for Democrats to embrace compassion and embark on the journey of creating a movement that resonates with the diverse fabric of American society.
